"

From 2012.igem.org

• Home
• Team
• Project
  • Why Beadzillus?
  • Bacillus Introduction
  • Bacillus BioBrickBox
  • GerminationSTOP
  • Sporobeads
  • Data
  • Applications
• Extras
  • Attributions
  • Collaborations
  • Registry
  • Bacillus Strains
  • Special: Inverter
  • Achievements
• Safety
  • Project Safety
  • Release for application
• Lab Notebook
  • Weekly Journal
  • Protocols
• Human Practice
  • SynBio Day
  • Students Practical Course
  • CAS SynBio Conference
  • Berlin Conference
• Sponsors

GerminationSTOP

The goal of this module was to yield Sporobeads which are safe (unable to germinate) and consistently functional (maintain their spore shape and structure throughout time). To achieve this, we sought to remove the germination capability of our spores, while keeping their necessary structural functions intact.

Two approaches were used to achieve this:

• Knock out genes that are involved in germination.

• Suicideswitch: Toxin production by vegetative cells if germination knockout fails and spores manage to germinate.

How do Sporulation & Germination Work?

Fig. 1: Taken from [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19554258 Kim, J. & Schumann W (2009)]. A: Cell at stage 0; vegetative phase. B: Cell at stage II; asymmetric septum has been formed. C: Cell at stage III; cytoplasmic membrane has engulfed forespore. D: Cell at stage IV; coat formation has started; spore will be released from lysed mother cell.

Sporulation: The Bacillus life cycle can include both classic division as well as reproduction by sporulation and spore germination. In response to nutrient starvation, Bacillus cells form endospores in a process called sporulation (Fig. 1). The “mother” cell forms the endospore within its own cytoplasm. The endospore contains its DNA in the spore core, which is protected by several layers of coats. The outermost layer is the spore crust. The spore is very dry, and contains a substance called dipicolinic acid (DPA), which replaced water to protect the DNA. Until the spore hydrates and swells out of its protective coats, it is resistant to a wide variety of environmental stressors, including UV radiation, toxic chemicals, freezing, high heat, dessication, and pH extremes. This resistance to stressors allows the spore to survive almost indefinitely until conditions are again ideal for growth.

Germination: On its inner spore membrane, the spore has germinant receptors. The spore coats are believed to be semipermeable or porous, in order to permit the passage of germinants to the receptors. When germinants such as amino acids and sugars reach the receptors, the spore begins the biophysical process of germination (see Fig. 2). Initially, the spore replaces its DPA with water (Stages I and II in Fig. 2), shifts its pH (Stage I), and swells (Stage II). Lytic enzymes break down the rigid spore coat layers encapsulating the spore's core (Stage II), allowing the spore core to swell further and begin the outgrowth process into a vegetative cell (Outgrowth). When the spore coat is broken down by lytic enzymes, the spore's environmental resistance is lost. For our project, we wish to prevent this germination process.

Fig. 2: The germination process in Bacillus spores. Taken from [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14662349 Setlow 2003].

How do Germination Gene Knockouts Work?

Our idea of how to prevent germination from occurring is to knock out genes encoding functions involved in the germination process. There are a huge number of genes which play a role in germination, but our goal was to select a few very essential genes to knock out.

Based on the research of others, the genes we chose were cwlJ, sleB, cwlB, gerD, and cwlD. Past works of [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19554258 J. Kim and W. Schumann (2009)] and [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11466293 B. Setlow et al (2001)] showed:

• cwlJ and sleB: when knocked out together, germination frequency was reduced by 5 orders of magnitude. Both genes code for lytic enzymes which are active in the process of germination.
• gerD and cwlB: When knocked out together, germination frequency was reduced by 5 orders of magnitude.  The gerD product plays an unknown role in nutrient germination; the product of cwlB plays a role in cell wall turnover & cell lysis. Note: after several attempts to knock out cwlB, and yielding cells unable to grow or cells growing at a very slow rate, we decided that knocking out cwlB would not be prudent for the production of Sporobeads, as it would delay all experiments in the GerminationSTOP module.
• cwlD: When knocked out, germination occurred at a rate of 0.003 to 0.05%. This gene codes for recognition components for cleavage by the germination-specific cortex lytic enzymes.

By knocking out all five of these genes, our goal was to yield a B. subtilis strain which produces spores completely incapable of germination. Germination is stopped during the process of spore coat breakdown. Without the lytic enzymes to break down the coat, the spores should be unable to outgrow into the vegetative stage.

Germination Genes	Encoded Function	Mutant Germination Rate
gerD	Unknown role in nutrition germination	Reduction by 5 orders of magnitude
cwlJ	Germination-specific lytic enzymes	0.003 – 0.05% No ATP detected
sleB	Germination-specific lytic enzymes	0.003 – 0.05% No ATP detected
cwlD	Recognition component for lytic enzymes	0.003 – 0-005%

Germination Gene Knockout Success!

Two methods were employed to knock out germination genes: replacement by resistance cassettes and clean deletions. Resistance cassette knockouts were generated by using long-flanking homology PCR (see Protocols). Single knockouts were created first using different resistance cassettes; then they were combined to create multiple knockouts. A graphical representation of the genome with all gene replacements can be seen in Fig 3.

Fig. 3: Schematic representation of the B. subtilis chromosome with four germination genes replaced by different resistance cassettes. For more information about these knockout strains, please see our Strain Collection.

The germination rate of our mutants was checked with a germination assay, shown in Fig. 4. The assay was developed based on published protocols.

Fig. 4: The germination rates of B. subtilis germination mutants. All germination rates are relative to wild type 168 (W168), our positive control. W168 showed near 100% germination rates. The mutant spo0A::tet is unable to form spores, and should therefore show no germination (our negative control). Our results were consistent with this expectation. Mutants used were: W168: wild-type 168 spo0A::tet: a sporulation-deficient strain B29: cwlD::kan, sleB::mls B30: gerD::cm, sleB::mls B32: cwlJ::spec, cwlD::kan B40: cwlD::kan, sleB::mls, cwlJ::spec B41: cwlD::kan, sleB::mls, gerD::cm B42: cwlD::kan, cwlJ::spec, gerD::cm B43: gerD::cm, sleB::mls, cwlJ::spec B46: cwlD::kan, cwlJ::spec, gerD::cm, sleB::mls B47: gerD::cm, sleB::mls, cwlJ::spec, cwlD::kan

We were able to achieve germination rates as low as <1 in 4.6x10⁹ spores in our triple mutant B43. Other mutants also showed extremely reduced germination ability. A table of germination rates of our mutants and all of the other spectacular results can be found on our results page. Our single mutants were not checked in the germination assay. The double and triple mutants tested showed mixed results, with some unable to germinate, and others maintaining low germination abilities. Our quadruple mutants demonstrated no ability to germinate, even in several separate germination assays.

Despite this success, safety was a top priority for this project. In the event that some small percentage of spores retained the ability to germinate, the Suicideswitch subproject (below) prevents outgrowth into viable vegetative cells.

Suicideswitch

Fig. 5: Genetic elements of the Suicideswitch and its expected performance.

As a backup plan to make our Sporobeads even safer, we developed the Suicideswitch. In case the spores do germinate, due to degradation or destruction of their outer coats, e.g. by high pressure, the Suicideswitch will be turned on.

We take advantage of an alternative and heterologous σ factor and the target promoter. Both are not present in B. subtilis and therefore not recognized by any other σ factor of B. subtilis.

The alternative sigma factor [http://partsregistry.org/wiki/index.php?title=Part:BBa_K823043 ecf41_{Bli aa1-204}] ([http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3426412/ Wecke T. et al 2012]), which derives from B. licheniformis a truncated version constitutively "ON" is synthetically linked to one out of two σ^G-regulated promoters ([http://partsregistry.org/wiki/index.php?title=Part:BBa_K823048 P_spoIVB] ([http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15699190 Steil L. et al. 2005]) responding strongly or [http://partsregistry.org/wiki/index.php?title=Part:BBa_K823042 P_sspK] ([http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15699190 Steil L., Völker U. et al. 2005]) responding weakly). σ^G is the last σ factor activated in the forespore. Consequently, Ecf41_{Bli aa1-204} is produced quite late and only in the forespore. Ecf41_{Bli aa1-204} then activates its unique target promoter [http://partsregistry.org/wiki/index.php?title=Part:BBa_K823041 P_ydfG] ([http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3426412/ Wecke T., Mascher T. 2012]). This promoter is fused to [http://partsregistry.org/wiki/index.php?title=Part:BBa_K823044 MazF] ([http://jcs.biologists.org/content/118/19/4327.abstract Engelberg-Kulka H.,Amitai S. 2005]). Activation of P_ydfG therefore leads to the expression of MazF, a bacterial toxin from E.coli degrading mRNA.

The resulting time course of expression is as follows: Sporulation of the Sporobeads leads to Ecf41_{Bli aa1-204} production in the forespore at the end of the differentiation cycle, through the activation of either P_spoIVB or P_sspK. Subsequently, this would lead to the expression of MazF, due to the activation of P_ydfG. For our already matured Sporobeads, this would not be toxic, as they represent a dormant state that does not require translation any more. But in the case that a Sporobead escapes the GerminationSTOP based on the gene knockouts described above, a germinating cell will already contain or soon start producing MazF and therefore kill the vegetative cells.

See what Data we got when measuring a module with luxABCDE instead of MazF.

We are planning to model this system, but still need more quantitative, time-resolved data for it. We hope to get this data after finishing the cloning of P_sspK and MazF into B. subtilis.